search web kakiseni
[ go ]

member login

register now | why register?
registration/login problems?



BOH Cameronian Arts Awards

"Progressive art can assist people to learn not only about the objective forces at work in the society in which they live, but also about the intensely social character of their interior lives. Ultimately, it can propel people toward social emancipation."

- Angela Y Davis
You are not logged in.
articles

Chee Sek Thim -- the man responsible for only so much.

A wayang kulit performance used in the opening scene.

A well-choreographed fight scene.

High kicks without a kick.

Some of the cast going beyond the monotonous ...

... but with the end near, it's sadly not enough.

 View on multiple pages

26. 10. 2007
Tembak: Sunway University College’s DP + M’s “Lao Jiu – Ninth Born” by Tengku Amalia

The stage is dark, save for a dimly lit section on my right-hand side. The Grand Puppet Master Tan (Sharifah Sofia) sits cross-legged among her students, her face calm with concentration. She carries with her a bunch of crudely made puppets. She takes a deep breath and begins her story. She tells us of a tale, of a monster and the scholar who confronts him of his evil deeds. The Master weaves her puppets in the air; they exchange clashes and blows, her voice becoming more frantic and louder as she goes on. Then she hits a particularly high note and I could feel the vocal cords in my throat cringe as it became obvious that she was running out of breath.

This, I noticed became a very regular occurrence during the rendition of Kuo Pao Kun’s “Lao Jiu – The Ninth Born” for Sunway University College Department of Performance + Media’s (DP+M). The play revolves around Lao Jiu, the only son out of nine siblings, golden child to his manual labourer of a father and housewife mother and, as the play opens, the chosen applicant of an extremely prestigious scholarship.

What follows next, is the usual: Lao Jiu snaps under the pressure and begins to question whether or not he would like to have his life fully planned out. He seeks solace at Grand Master Tan’s puppetry place in the hills. His family, horrified that their only chance of escaping hardship is being thrown away, try to reason with the boy, even resorting to force to try and bring him back to his senses.

Directed by Chee Sek Thim (“That Was The Year”, “The Coffin is Too Big for the Hole”), the play is divided into segments, each with an individual title and different performance genre. The opening was a wayang kulit performance while an excellently choreographed fight scene was used for the “Blame Game” segment where Lao Jiu’s family members argue who’s to blame for the boy’s disappearance. Of course, no play of Chee Sek Thim’s could go without an Incredible Showcase Of Amazing Acrobatic Skills.

However, aside from the casts’ Incredible Showcase Of Amazing Acrobatic Skills, everything else became quite neglected.

Like someone following an exercise video, the cast seemed rather content to have allowed their bodies to go through the motions rather than conveying any believable emotion whatsoever. It seemed that they were so focused on getting a high-kick right that they have forgotten about living within the moment. Therefore, scenes that require something beyond a physical-skill showcase became rather wanting.

One such moment was when Father (Nicholas Liew) confronted the Grand Master Tan about Lao Jiu (Ruby Ooi). Here, we saw two desperate people whose livelihoods depended on whether Lao Jiu would choose to further his studies or remain with the puppets. The resulting argument made me feel as though I was watching two ladies buying groceries at the store. When the discovery was made that Master Tan is dying of throat cancer and has only two years to live, I had to fight the urge to yawn.

There were times when it seemed like the cast was going somewhere beyond their monotonous acting. This was evident in the final confrontation between Lao Jiu and his family. Nicholas manages to convey his Father’s extreme anger and disappointment with Lao Jiu. For once, you could sympathise with this man who is unable to comprehend why his son would want to throw away such a brilliant scholarship and the chance to help his family just for the sake of a dying art-form. It made Lao Jiu’s rebuttal of wanting to have his own way look like a tantrum of a spoilt child.

By this time, unfortunately, we reached the end of the play and whatever sympathy incited was not enough to override the fact that we simply did not care for most of the characters to invest any more emotionally.

Ruby Ooi’s Lao Jiu was quite weak; you never get to feel the young boy’s breakdown, desperation and his determination to carve his own path. The Mother (Valerie Chai) and Lao Jiu’s sisters and their husbands (Afiq Nazmi, Ivan Wong, Bonno Jackson, Yasmin Martin, Elza Irdalynna) felt like caricatures serving forced levity. Sharifah Sofia’s Master Tan looked as though she could sink into the wall at any moment. The only character that came rather close to achieving any semblance of a likeable individual was Nicholas Liew but even then, his portrayal barely scratched the surface.

It was strange that a play emphasising the need to follow one’s heart sorely lacked one itself.

~ ~ ~

Tengku Amalia is a freelance writer and is currently working at Valentine Willie Fine Art.

DP+M’s “Lao Jiu – The Ninth Born” ran from Thu 18 - Sun 21 Oct 2007 (Thu - Sat: 8.30pm; Sun: 3pm) at Sunway University College’s Rooftop Theatre.

Performance photos courtesy of Pang Kee Teik and Sunway University College.

 View on multiple pages

User Comments

posted by rogue shadow @ Elza Irdalynna, Tue 06.11.200712:06:54 PM
whoa, there, kambing. i did not mean that Amalia was being disloyal to the college at all. i meant she was professional enough to not be biased toward the college. i agree with her review. i thought the show lacked so much potential. what was under the lights were ideas, but they were so poorly executed, they never materialized. excuse my bluntness, but it simply sucked.

i should know. i was in it.

 

posted by Eric Tay, Thu 01.11.200708:45:54 AM
Readers say: (Outstanding post!)
Rogue Shadow and Kambing,a review is a review. It's a very subjective matter.Some people like it and some don't.You are in theater and should know better that it's impossible to please all.
The whole fiasco about karma, please do some growing up. Writing out of rage and not thinking is just plain immature. A review is to help us improve, take it as a lesson. Don't use the whole "betraying" situation as an excuse, Amalia is just doing her job and is brave enough to voice out her opinion.
Next time use your real name and not come up with stupid pseudonym.

 

posted by Amelia Chen, Mon 29.10.200720:59:06 PM
Readers say: (Outstanding post!)
First up...Kambing.....GROW A BACKBONE. If you're going to be snide (to your senior no less) at least have the decency to own up. And just because we came from the same course, doesn't mean we have to accept and praise anything and everything that comes out of it. GROW UP.Think for yourself. And the whole karma spiel... please heed your own advice.

Secondly. I agree with Amalia somewhat. For the show I went for, they cranked up the music...a wee bit too loudly, drowning out most of the dialogue...but I have to agree that to a certain extent, the show lacked a certain amount of "je ne se que" or soul. There were odd bits here and there but that was it.

But it was entertaining tho.

Sek Thim cleverly melded wayang/shadow-puppetry with live action. And of course included his own unique brand of physical theatre. Which I enjoy watching...and to a certain extent, performing too!

 

posted by Kambing, Mon 29.10.200713:40:52 PM
Readers say: (Everyone's entitled to their opinion)
i agree with the person wrote the first comment...i couldn't believe that you wrote this review bad about OUR college performance...and you came from SUNWAY COLLEGE...but...what the hell...it's your review...it will reflect back to you someday..somehow...

 

posted by Rogue Shadow, Mon 29.10.200710:39:41 AM
Readers say: (Everyone's entitled to their opinion)
Amalia, thanks for your honest comment, and props on bein professional enough to not care that you came from the same college that produced Lao Jiu. Honestly, i couldn't agree with you more about the play. Thanks again for the reality check, babe.

 

Related Links

print | e-mail to a friend | post comment